More Toronto Blue Jays ‘Off season Targets’:
Edwin Encarnación
Dallas Keuchel
David Price
Justin Smoak
Jake Odorizzi (Accepted qualifying offer from Minnesota on Nov. 14)
Zack Wheeler
Wade Miley
Next up, Japanese first baseman/left fielder Yoshitomo Tsutsugo.
Over the past several years, Yoshitomo Tsutsugo has been among the
preeminent sluggers in Japanese baseball. But after 10 seasons playing
in Nippon Professional Baseball, Tsutsugo wants to play in North
America. Earlier this month, the 28-year-old, lefty slugger was made
available to all 30 MLB clubs via the Japanese posting process.
How the posting system works: Any MLB team is free to sign him by
paying a fee to his current team, the Yokohama DeNA Bay Stars. Teams have
until 5 p.m. ET Dec. 19 to agree to terms.
Tsutsugo debuted for Yokohama in 2010 at 18 but played only three
games that season. By 2014, he was a full-time player appearing in 114
games and batting .300/.373/.529 with 22 home runs. In every season
since then, he’s hit at least 22 home runs, including 44 in 2016 when he
led the league. Tsutsugo is now the captain of his club, a respected
teammate and a popular face of the franchise. He’s also represented
Japan on the international stage, including at the 2017 World Baseball
Classic.
Off the field, calling for less tournament-style play and stricter pitch limits to protect young arms.
After the Bay Stars were eliminated in the 2019 playoffs, Tsutsugo
announced his intention to play in MLB. Over his 10-year career in
Japan, Tsutsugo has hit .285 with a .910 OPS and 205 home runs. As for
the rest of his game, he’s not known for his baserunning skills, thanks
to his stocky, 6-foot, 210-pound build. Defensively, he’s spent most of
his time in left field, but he also has experience at first and third
base. He’s not considered a plus-defender at any position.
Naturally, there are questions surrounding Tsutsugo’s possible move
to the majors: Will his power translate? How will he fare facing more
elite pitching? What position will he play?
His raw power is intriguing, so while he’s a bit of a wild card,
he’ll have no shortage of off-season suitors, including perhaps Toronto.
Tsutsugo’s 2019 in review:
Statistically, this past season was Tsutsugo’s least productive since
2013. In 131 games (557 PAs), he slashed .272/.388/.511, although he
still hit 29 home runs, and posted an above-average 15.8 percent walk
rate. However, he stuck out more than usual — 141 times — with a
career-worst strikeout rate of 25.3 percent.
Defensively, Tsutsugo moved from left field to third base for the
first time since 2014 after the Bay Stars’ regular third baseman broke
his finger in August. And while he wasn’t elite at the hot corner,
Tsutsugo was serviceable, according to Jim Allen, who has written about
Japanese baseball for more than two decades and currently writes for
Kyodo News.
“It’s not that he could play it OK, but it didn’t bother his offence at all,” Allen said.
Following the season, after the second-place Bay Stars were upset in
the first round of the playoffs by the third-place Hanshin Tigers,
Tsutsugo was emotional — not only because of the loss, but also due to
the fact he had likely played his last game of Japanese baseball.
Here’s what teammate Spencer Patton, a relief pitcher with the Bay Stars since 2017, told The Athletic about his captain.
“He felt as the leader of the team, and us getting beat out in the
first round of the playoffs, he felt responsibility to stay and help the
team win a championship,” said Patton, who made 52 appearances in the
majors between 2014-16, before moving overseas. “But he said he wanted
to come over to the States and try to get better and try to compete with
the best players in the world. I think it’s about testing his skills
and proving that he can do it — to himself and to everyone else. I think
that’s ultimately why anybody pursues Major League Baseball; to say
that you got a chance to compete with the best players in the world.”
Quote that best sums up Tsutsugo’s 2019:
“Of course, it’s baseball, so batting and defence and base running are all important,” “I can’t assess myself. But I can say for sure I’ll do the best I can.”
How is Tsutsugo trending?
Tsutsugo is a gifted fly-ball hitter with exceptional raw power.
FanGraphs reported that he averaged 92 m.p.h. off the bat last season in
the NPB, a number that in MLB would have placed him among the top 30
players in 2019. He’s a natural pull-hitter, but he can still hit the
ball the other way with power to centre and left-centre.
Patton said Tsutsugo’s power to the opposite field is one of his most impressive attributes.
“Most guys that are pull hitters are yanking balls down the line and
really driving the ball over the pull side a lot, (and) really struggle
hitting good quality pitches to the other side,” Patton said. “But
Tsutsugo, he’s hitting doubles off the wall to left-centre and he’ll
have no problem beating shifts over there.”
How his power translates to the majors, however, is the big unknown.
One of the challenges for Tsutsugo will be how he adapts to MLB
pitching, specifically, facing guys who on a regular basis throw 95 and
up with elite breaking stuff. In Japan, there are some pitchers who
throw 95-plus, but not many.
According to Allen, Tsutsugo has struggled to hit upper-90s fastballs in his career.
“Anything 95 and up inside is probably going to eat him up,” he said.
So he’ll need to work on his timing at the plate. That said, Tsutsugo
has excellent plate discipline. He can also crush breaking balls — and
if you can do it in Japan, where breaking stuff tends to be nastier, you
can probably do it over here — and punish mistake pitches.
“What I see from him, he’s going to force people to throw fastballs,”
Allen said. “He’s going to force people who throw mediocre fastballs to
throw them, and he’ll crush them. I think that 25 to 30 home runs is
not an impossibility and because he’s a left-handed hitter, of course,
he’ll have the platoon advantage most of the time. I see him as being a
fairly useful player.”
Defensively, Tsutsugo has drawbacks. In the outfield, he has a weak
arm and he’s not quick. He’s likely limited to a corner outfield spot,
first base or DH. He can play third base, but ideally not on a regular
basis. Because of these limitations, there are questions about where
exactly Tsutsugo fits on an MLB diamond.
“I think he can play,” said Patton. “I think he can find a spot on
the roster and play and be beneficial to a team — but in my opinion, I
don’t know what position he would play.”
Thanks to the excellent work of colleague Eno Sarris, we have an idea of how the 28-year-old might perform in the majors.
But briefly, by using Clay Davenport’s website to translate Tsutsugo’s
Japanese stats into MLB equivalent numbers, Sarris projects Tsutsugo
could slash .271/.339/.442 next season. From there, Sarris combined his
offensive projections with his poor base running and defence and found
that J.D. Davis, (Mets), Ji-Man Choi (Rays) and Brandon Belt (Giants)
were apt comparables.
Why Tsutsugo is a fit for the Blue Jays:
Earlier this offseason, Blue Jays general manager Ross Atkins
expressed interest in adding a first baseman who could play multiple
positions. Tsutsugo fits the bill there, even if he won’t be a Gold
Glove candidate. As a lefty bat, Tsutsugo would also give the Jays’
right-handed heavy lineup some balance. Although, his addition would
rule out any possible platoon with fellow lefty Rowdy Tellez.
When asked directly about Tsutsugo earlier this month at the GM
meetings, Atkins admitted the team has looked at the Japanese slugger.
“He’s an exciting hitter and versatile,” “An interesting player, for sure.”
He’s not projected to be a star, but he has the chance to be an
average-to-slightly-above-average major-leaguer. Even if his home run
rates drop, his ability to get on base and draw walks should hold
steady, which is an area Toronto needs to improve in. In terms of
intangibles, Tsutsugo is said to have an outgoing, positive personality
and a strong work ethic, useful traits during a rebuild.
“I think getting used to failing at that level is probably not going to get him down,” Allen said.
That said, any team acquiring him may need to be patient. A
contending club may be unwilling to wait out potential early struggles,
but with a young roster, a rebuilding team like the Blue Jays may be
able to offer him more runway.
According to Patton, Tsutsugo has tried to connect with his foreign
teammates, picking up a few words in English and Spanish. In 2015-16, he
played a season of Dominican Winter Ball.
“He’s just eager to learn other cultures and try to speak different
languages and stuff like that,” Patton said. “He’s a great guy to have
in the clubhouse. He’s not strict about anything or tries to be too hard
on people. He likes to keep it light and play around and then once it’s
time to go between the lines, then it’s all business.”
Why Tsutsugo might not be a fit for the Blue Jays:
There are a lot of unknowns regarding Tsutsugo and how he’ll fare in
the majors. Because of that, there seems to be a wide variance in
expectations. Allen called him a “wild card.”
“He has a high upside,” he said. “He has a super-high ceiling
compared to the other guys who are (being posted). He could be a guy who
could hit 30 home runs, 35, depending on the park. Or, he could be a
guy who basically has no role because he’s essentially a 28-year-old
Triple-A player with poor defence who can hit 25 home runs. So, there’s
that gap.”
With the way the ball flies in the majors now, hitting 20-25 home
runs is more commonplace and therefore, what Tsutsugo offers may not be
that hard to find elsewhere. There is also a chance that he is a
complete bust.
Meanwhile, the Blue Jays have also been a bottom tier defensive team
over the past two seasons and must get better in that area. Tsutsugo
won’t help them there.
But currently, three of the six current Japanese major leaguers (Shohei
Ohtani, Yusei Kikuchi, Kenta Maeda) play on the west coast, while
Yoshihisa Hirano is in Arizona. Yu Darvish is with the Cubs, while
Masahiro Tanaka plays for the Yankees.
The likely competition:
Milwaukee is a logical landing spot for Tsutsugo,
The Brewers declined a team option on Eric Thames — who himself was a
successful international signing after he played three seasons in Korea —
and are now in the market for another first baseman.
The Mariners, Nationals, White Sox or Angels could also be potential fits.
Dollars and Sense:
Because Tsutsugo would be acquired via the posting system, his
financials are a little more complicated than merely signing a free
agent. Per the revised rules of the posting system, the MLB team that
signs Tsutsugo would need to pay his Japanese club a posting fee that is
calculated using the guaranteed money in the contract. Teams pay 20
percent of the first $25 million, 17.5 percent of the next $25 million
and 15 percent of any amount above $50 million. For a minor-league
contract, the fee is a flat 25 percent. In essence, a club is playing
Tsutsugo a salary, plus a little more, to acquire him.
Kiley McDaniel projects he could earn a two-year deal at $8 million per
year, while the median projection for the Japanese slugger is a
four-year deal worth $40 million for an AAV of $10 million.
Whatever he ends up signing for, Allen suggested Tsutsugo could be a
“bargain” because of his makeup and intangibles. “They’re going to get
more, I think, than scouts see. I think because of the makeup and
because of his attitude and his desire.”
Tsutsugo is a proven slugger in the NPB, but there’s no guarantee his
game will succeed in North America. He has swing-and-miss in his game,
and that could accelerate in the majors, where he’ll face elite pitching
on a more regular basis. And with little to offer defensively, his
success will rely primarily on whether he can produce offensively.
He has the chance to
be an above-average hitter, although as Eno Sarris points out, he can
contribute, but he likely won’t move the needle for a big-budget
contender.
Not yet a contender, the Blue Jays could be a nice landing spot for
Tsutsugo, where he won’t face the pressure to immediately perform, the
way he might with a contending team. He fits the Atkins-preferred mould
as a first baseman who can play other positions, and at 28, he’s younger
than many of the free agents out there. If he pans out, he should still
be in his prime years when the Blue Jays hope to become AL East
contenders.
The Blue Jays could be a fit for Tsutsugo. But does the upside outweigh the potential risk?