The
interest coincided with a pair of desires for Freese. He wanted to stay
in Los Angeles. And he sought to avoid the demeaning, depleting process
that free agency has become. He figured he would prefer retirement to
waiting until March for a new deal. So he let the Dodgers cut his pay to $5 million, and sounded thrilled with the outcome.
“It was honestly great not to go into the market,” Freese said this past weekend at Dodgers Fan Fest.
A day after Freese re-signed, the process repeated on a grander scale. Clayton Kershaw avoided free agency
by agreeing to a three-year, $93-million contract. Rather than use his
potential departure as a cudgel, Kershaw leveraged his theoretical
freedom into effectively what was a one-year extension. He preferred the
comfort of the Dodgers over the uncertainty of the market. Hyun-Jin Ryu made a similar choice, opting for the team’s one-year, $17.9-million qualifying offer rather than seeking a larger, lengthier deal with other clubs.
Who knows why neither have signed. Maybe it's an elaborate game of chicken.
Across
the last three decades, as Major League Baseball emerged from the
late-1980s scandal of collusion and began to compensate its workforce
without manipulated prices, the players treated free agency as a
panacea. It was the reward for the years spent riding minor-league buses
down dusty roads. It was why they accepted three years of a
league-mandated minimum salary, and three more potentially fighting with
their employers in arbitration. Free agency was the goal.
If
a player was fortunate enough to make it through that sluice with his
health and skills intact, he could reap the reward of the open market.
Yet
the winter of 2019 has reinforced the foreshadowing from last winter.
Those days are gone. The compensation system for baseball players is not
broken, but it has mutated in a way that has squeezed out those who had
become comfortable with the old paradigm.
Two
weeks shy of pitchers and catchers reporting for work this season, the
list of available free agents extends beyond the high-profile duo of
Bryce Harper and Manny Machado. Dallas Keuchel, two-time all-star and
former Cy Young Award winner, remains unsigned. So does seven-time
all-star closer Craig Kimbrel. Multiple other former all-stars are
available.
More
revealing is the brevity of contracts that have been given out. Only
four players — Washington Nationals pitcher Patrick Corbin, ,
Boston Red Sox pitcher Nathan Eovaldi and Seattle Mariners pitcher
Yusei Kikuchi — have netted contracts longer than three years. Fifteen
teams have spent fewer than $25 million on free agents this winter.
Consider
the case of former Dodgers catcher Yasmani Grandal. Heading into his
age-30 season, he averaged 24 home runs and a .799 on-base plus slugging
percentage during the previous three years. His production outpaced
that of catcher Brian McCann, who inked a five-year, $85-million
contract with the New York Yankees before the 2014 season at the same
age after averaging 21 homers and a .770 OPS. Grandal settled with Milwaukee.
The
era of the irrational eight- or nine-figure payday has ended, as
executives have seen the folly of deals awarded to players such as
Chicago Cubs outfielder Jason Heyward and
Baltimore Orioles first baseman Chris Davis .
“Data
is laying it out there on how guys play, how they show up later on in
these huge deals,” Freese said. “And I guess it’s just not panning out.
So teams are just not going to throw that out there — especially if
there aren’t more than a team or two fighting for a certain player.
Especially if you’re in your 30s.”
Freese understood the logic. But he still fretted over the implications.
“I
don’t like it,” he said. “I don’t think it needs to be like that. We
understand how much money is out there, and the question is: where is
the fans’ money going?”
Both
Harper and Machado are 26, but have still been caught in this storm. In
recent years, the proliferation of teams tanking in the hopes of
rebuilding has been replaced by a more subtle scourge. No longer does
half the industry abdicate winning in an effort to replicate how the
Chicago Cubs and the Houston Astros assembled their championship clubs.
But a majority of the sport has embraced austerity, even the
large-market clubs who once used financial might to lord over rivals.
The
Yankees diverted their offseason resources to a horde of relievers and
second baseman D.J. LeMahieu, rather than Harper and Machado. The Cubs
preferred to bring back shortstop Addison Russell, who was suspended in
October for violating the sport’s domestic-violence policy, instead of
pursuing Machado. Needing to fill a hole in their outfield, the Astros
opted for a two-year, $32-million contract with Michael Brantley, a good
player who lacks the stratospheric upside of Harper.
The Dodgers have scant interest in Machado and tepid interest in Harper, but they’ve still spent more than most.
No comments:
Post a Comment